close
close

An Augusta County investigator was able to get the assault charge dropped

An Augusta County investigator was able to get the assault charge dropped

STAUNTON – An Augusta County Sheriff’s Office investigator who was convicted of felonious assault in Staunton in February appealed the convictions and received a more favorable outcome last week that could result in the charges being dismissed.

Inv. CJ Taylor was charged in Staunton following a 2022 incident involving two men. The investigator was looking for a suspect when Antwhon Suiter, a self-described constitutional activist, and Christopher Shifflett came across a police crime scene.

Testimony from February showed Suiter and Shifflett were on their way to a local supermarket to buy groceries when they noticed a police vehicle in town. Suiter turned on his car’s dashboard camera and began recording as he tracked the vehicle, along with a second vehicle, to Reservoir Hill Park. Both men exited Suiter’s vehicle and were filming on their cell phones as Taylor approached them.

Video of the incident shows Taylor confronting Shifflett, who was holding a phone. Taylor pulls out a pair of handcuffs and grabs Shifflett by the wrist before knocking the phone out of his hand and throwing him to the ground. According to testimony, he was handcuffed and held briefly before being released without charge.

Suiter testified that Taylor also grabbed his wrist and phone.

At the February hearing, defense attorney Tripp Franklin argued that Suiter’s hand was only grabbed “for a second” and said Taylor’s confrontation with Shifflett was not aggressive.

General District Court Judge Robin Mayer convicted Taylor of both misdemeanor charges.

But Franklin immediately appealed the case and adjourned the case for a two-day jury trial in Staunton Circuit Court later this month. But Franklin said he and Don Caldwell, a special prosecutor assigned from Roanoke to handle the case, canceled the trial after they were able to reach a deal.

Taylor maintained his innocence and pleaded not guilty last week. The two charges were dealt with under a deferred disposition. Based on Caldwell’s offer, Franklin said the court found the facts in the case were sufficient to convict the investigator. Instead, the case will be deliberated for 12 months. If Taylor continues to remain disorderly, the charges will be dismissed in a year, Franklin said.

“And in particular, I would like to note that the parties have entered into an agreement that the charges can be expunged once they are dismissed,” Franklin said. “That doesn’t always happen.”

The lawyer added: “It’s a great result for CJ.”

Reached for comment Thursday, Augusta County Sheriff Donald Smith declined due to a pending $2 million federal lawsuit from Suiter.

Taylor was placed on administrative leave pending an internal investigation.

More: New home and garden store opens in downtown Staunton

More: Waynesboro man charged with killing in July jumped bail in front of dozens of supporters

Brad Zinn is a police officer, courtroom and breaking news reporter for The News Leader. Do you have a news tip? Or something that needs to be investigated? You can email reporter Brad Zinn (he/him) at [email protected]. You can also follow him on X (formerly Twitter).

Related Post