The FOX drama sparks controversy

When Accused It premiered on FOX and became a hit, but failed to meet the expectations of a network TV audience. In its first season, the series was as uncompromising and intense as the British crime drama on which it was based – with actors who tried hard. Accused Season 2 jumps right back into the fire with an episode that will likely leave viewers arguing about several different aspects of the story… and that’s what it’s all about.

Season 2, Episode 1, “Lorraine’s Story,” is about a woman who claims to be a psychic medium but is charged with fraud when her latest vision fails to produce results. Viewers will debate whether or not Lorraine Howell is actually psychic, but the real story is about how her actions tear apart what’s left of a family that seemingly could no longer suffer. It’s uncomfortably complicated, beautifully acted and there’s no right answer as to why Accused remains the best drama on television.

Felicity Huffman leads the second season premiere of Accused

The episode rests largely on Huffman’s shoulders

Accused deserves to be one of the best anthology series on television because great care was taken into every aspect of the production – especially the casting. It’s clear that showrunner Howard Gordon and his team understand that if they want to go into difficult and complicated narrative places, they need to find not only great actors who can nail those nuances, but also the right actors who can really suit every role. “Lorraine’s Story” casts Felicity Huffman as a defendant, which will likely draw some comment given Huffman’s own legal troubles. But this attitude to life imitating art gives the episode a different energy. The key question is whether or not viewers trust Lorraine, which is harder to answer when they may also be divided about how they perceive the actor playing her. And when Lorraine has a tearful breakdown and talks about all she’s lost, Huffman taps into emotions so deep that perhaps wouldn’t have been possible for someone who hasn’t had her experiences.

Lorraine claims to have psychic visions about missing children and sees a news report about the disappearance of Rory Conley, whose parents Frank and Melissa are still desperate for closure a year later. Against the advice of Ray (played by Huffman’s own husband William H. Macy), Lorraine tips off the police and is soon invited to stay at the Conleys’ house in the hopes that she will have another vision that leads to Rory’s safe return. Accused quickly reveals why that didn’t happen, and Lorraine is now charged with fraud based on how much money she took from the Conleys over two months to pay off various debts. But Huffman plays the character with awkward sincerity throughout, allowing the audience to see that when the prosecutor claims that Lorraine was even deluding herself.

The decision to film this episode about an alleged psychic is the starting point of the controversy. The audience will have a fascinating debate about whether Lorraine really has a “gift”, whether she is a deliberate fraud or whether she has honestly constructed this image of herself – and it is all based on each person’s personal views.Accused provides evidence that points in all directions. Lorraine is credited with finding a missing girl in Nevada in 2007, but the detective’s credibility in the case is torn to shreds on the witness stand. She has every reason to be desperate for money. But more than that, “Lorraine’s Story” reveals how desperately she longs for human connection, too. The Season 2 premiere creates another multi-faceted character, played by another well-known actor, who brings exactly what the story demands.

Accused Season 2 Episode 1 presents a heartbreaking dilemma

The premiere offers more than just Lorraine’s story

It’s easy to see why FOX chose “Lorraine’s Story” as the title Accused Season 2 premiere because it’s actually a much fuller episode, even by this series’ standards. Each episode deals with a larger theme, but this episode actually has two storylines that have enough drama to fill two hours. The crux of the episode isn’t Lorraine’s guilt or innocence – it’s the emotional devastation of Rory’s parents Frank and Melissa, played by Daniel Maslany and Isabel Arraiza. The episode likes to use Frank and Melissa The X-Files‘ Mulder and Scully, the former being a believer and the latter a skeptic. And as great as Huffman is in the title role, it’s Arraiza who drives the episode forward with Melissa’s anger; She becomes the voice of the audience, saying whatever they want to say when it becomes clear that Lorraine is not what she wants to be.

Likewise, it will be legitimately painful to see how completely Frank is drawn into Lorraine’s orbit. It’s understandable that he wants to hold on to whatever gets his son back, and Accused lays some of the foundation in a kitchen scene in which he explains that he has always been the more relaxed of the two. But there is still a difference between blind faith and desperation so great that he decides to hold several press conferences in which he doubts the police investigation. And just moments after Lorraine is acquitted, he’s still handing her Rory’s hat and asking her for help. This part of the story perhaps goes a little too far… but the point is made nonetheless. Lorraine’s involvement in her son’s disappearance leads directly to the end of Frank and Melissa’s marriage, and it’s heartbreaking to watch.

The real question, then, is not Lorraine’s legal guilt, but rather what responsibility she bears for the harm her involvement has caused. Eventually she gets to go back to her home state with Ray and viewers know her life isn’t great, but what happens to Frank and Melissa after the credits roll? Here is Accused shines. Much like Season 1, Episode 11, “Morgan’s Story” screamed for a sequel, in “Lorraine’s Story” the audience is forced to consider larger consequences. The trials in each episode create a structure for each episode and a required end point. There is no guarantee that they will solve anything. This episode may be about Lorraine, but the real journey is for Frank and Melissa, leaving the audience wondering if they will ever find peace – or if Lorraine has committed another crime.

Related

The 10 Most Bingeable Crime Dramas

Between miniseries like “Sharp Objects” and longer TV series like “Ozark,” the most crime series will leave you wanting more.

Is Accused Season 2 as good as Season 1?

Season 2, Episode 1 is a fantastic start to the season

Accused In Season 1, the film set a very high bar for itself, thoroughly and fairly covering important issues like concerns about institutional racism in “Kendall’s Story.” It can only be successful if it is not just a big drama, but a platform to actually address these topics, otherwise the authors will only use current topics for entertainment. “Lorraine’s Story” proves that the writers still want to challenge what the audience knows, thinks and feels – and that they still won’t push the audience one way or the other. Viewers are left to make up their own minds, and whatever they take away is satisfying, in addition to the wonderful acting.

Some viewers will understandably be disappointed if Rory Conley’s fate isn’t explicitly mentioned somewhere in the episode. They say a man confesses to his murder, but Rory’s body is never found. The viewer wants that closure for themselves – but it makes story sense not to give it, as confirming that Rory is dead would also shed more light on Lorraine, and the episode wants to leave her as a mystery. Some fans may also lament the relative lack of screen time for Macy, as it’s nice to see him and Huffman on screen together again. But beyond those two aspects, Lorraine’s Story is a near-flawless hour of television and a triumphant return for a show that deserves far more attention.

Accused airs Tuesdays at 9 p.m. on FOX.

Each episode of this anthology series explores a different courtroom drama and reveals the story of a person on trial. Viewers see the history of the prosecution from the defendant’s perspective, culminating in the trial in which the truth is disputed.

Release date

January 22, 2023

Creator

Howard Gordon, Jimmy McGovern

Pour

Abigail Breslin, Malcolm-Jamal Warner, Jason Ritter, Keith Carradine, Molly Parker

Evaluation

Seasons

1

Streaming service(s)

Advantages

• The show remains the most powerful drama on television.
• Strong performances from the three main actors.

Disadvantages

• Audiences may be disappointed if they don’t have a clear idea of ​​Rory’s fate.

Expand