close
close

After another child abuse case, the judiciary skips the home school regulation bill from the special session. • West Virginia Watch

After another child abuse case, the judiciary skips the home school regulation bill from the special session. • West Virginia Watch

Gov. Jim Justice said there is a bill to address flaws in the state’s homeschool laws that allow students to go without registering.

Several high-profile child abuse and neglect cases in West Virginia last year involved homeschoolers.

Although the governor expressed concern about the situation, he did not take up the bill his call for a special meeting posted Saturday evening. The special session begins Monday in Charleston.

“We have a draft, but here lies the problem. We are aware of the tragedies that have happened. It is difficult to drive a round peg as far into a square hole as possible. “It looks like there’s nothing that fits,” Justice said said Friday during a press conference. “There is no question that we have to do better.

Some lawmakers have pushed for urgent measures on the issue and said it cannot wait until lawmakers gather for their next regular session in 2025.

Del. Anitra Hamilton, D-Monongalia

“At this point, the blood is on our hands because we are watching our children die and nothing is happening,” Del said. Anitra Hamiton, D-Monongalia, who serves on the House Education Committee.

This year, lawmakers considered suspending families’ applications for homeschooling if a teacher reports suspected child abuse. They have also discussed stricter follow-up of homeschool parents who have not provided required assessments of their students.

“Boy, what a complex topic. To be honest, this may be better in the general session than in a special session,” Justice said.

A deputy in September 2023 found two teenagers locked in a shed in Sissonville “devastating” conditionsincluding no access to running water or a toilet. The children were taught at home.

Then, in April, 14 years old Kyneddi Millerwho was be taught at homeShe was found dead “in a skeletal state” on the bathroom floor of her Boone County home.

On September 24th, an 8-year-old girl ran away from her home in handcuffs and looked for help in a Charleston neighborhood. TV station WCHS reported that the girl and other children in her home in the district were given residential school status.

The tragedies have left the judiciary and lawmakers on both sides at the altar deal with it How to balance the Republican supermajority’s school choice push with tightening homeschool regulations to prevent child abuse or deaths?

Del. JB Akers, R-Kanawha

“It’s a complicated issue because it involves basic parental rights, but also the intersection with the desire to do the right thing for the children,” Del said. JB Akers, R-Kanawha, who represents the area where the 8-year-old girl was found in handcuffs. “I think we also need to start from a place where homeschooling parents are not treated differently just because they chose to homeschool.”

Hamilton said the governor should take the lead on the issue because divisions in the House of Representatives, which includes several homeschool parents, make it difficult to have “productive conversations” on the issue despite the tragedies.

“When you bring it up, people don’t want to discuss anything more rigorous in the context of homeschooling. This is shocking to me when the majority of these people claim they are pro-life. For me, our number one goal is to protect children,” she said. “[Children] have a right to a productive education, but they also have a right to protection. I think we should set some parameters and I also think it should be a bipartisan conversation.”

Public schools are tasked with serving homeschool students

Parents or guardians are required Submit to the district superintendent the academic evaluations of the home-schooled student in grades three, five, eight and 11.

If no documentation is filed, state education law allows local school districts to take action against the family, but is not required to do so.

In West Virginia, more than 30,000 children are homeschooled. State education Data The study, published this year, showed that 57% of homeschooled students submitted required documentation on time. For students likely to be in 11th grade, the number fell to 37%.

Previously, the state schools superintendent was Michele Blatt recommended that requiring school staff to care for missing students could be a step toward solving the problem.

Akers noted that local school districts are likely already overwhelmed with maintaining truant public schools and homeschool student status.

“It’s fair to ask our school board, ‘Do you have the resources to meet the mandates placed on you?'” he said.

Lawmakers could also reconsider the debate over Raylee’s bill, which is included in his latest version would pause or potentially deny a parent’s request for home schooling if a teacher has reported suspected child abuse. The law was named after 8-year-old Raylee Browning. who died of abuse and neglect in 2018 in Fayette County after her parents pulled her out of school.

Akers supported Raylee’s bill, which was included in an amendment during the regular session. The House of Representatives passed The amendment received bipartisan support but was not passed by the Senate.

“I am not afraid that we will see an epidemic of bad faith reports because [teachers] are looking for homeschoolers,” he said, noting that falsely reporting child abuse is a crime.

The special session is expected to focus largely on Justice’s idea for one Reduction in income taxits child and dependent care tax credit and additional allocations of state dollars.

“At the end of the day, if I was told at the eleventh hour that we weren’t going to vote for this…why would we waste our time? If all we want to do is bring people down and have them spend government money and do nothing about this issue, then we don’t need this issue,” Justice said.

Related Post